Challenges Faced by Hearing Impairment Students During COVID-19

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________ Social distancing and other protocols required during the COVID-19 pandemic have been particularly difficult for students who are disabled, especially hearing impairments students. During the Covid-19, many disabled students were impacted physically, mentally and their interactions may have been hindered. That could be one of the barriers for full and active participation in society during the Covid19. Therefore, this study aims to discover the challenges faced by hearing impairment students how it affects the communication and mainstreaming process. The data was collected from ten hearing impairments students and analysed qualitatively. The participants were aged between 19-22 and currently studying foundation programme in culinary arts in a skill transformation center. The participants were interviewed using impromptu interview questions via WhatsApp, which lasted about ten minutes for each participant. The findings show that there were four challenges faced by the hearing impairment students; hearing devices, disruption to comprehend the lesson, not familiar with the online devices and emotionally affected during online classes. The findings further reveal that the hearing impairment students hampered their social interactions skills towards others during the pandemic. It is hoped the findings would be useful for academicians, counsellors, doctors and other job professions to explore further research on hearing impairments and the framing of methodology to assist the hearing impairments in engaging with the society during the pandemic.


www.msocialsciences.com
Malaysia Government has imposed an extreme measure to contain the deadly Covid-19 pandemic outbreak, and people were commended for staying at home and exercising social distancing. There are a group of people who have gone through some unexpected difficulties during the Covid-19, especially disable students.
In the very first time, humans have experienced a feeling of exclusion from ordinary life and a sense of isolation, according to the World Economic Forum (WEF) (Athira Nortajuddin, 2020). Nevertheless, for people with disabilities, the sense of isolation and daily experience of exclusion is nothing new and is considered a norm for many. It is estimated that 15% of the world's population has a disability. As huge populations are anxious and impatiently waiting for businesses to resume and for life to return to normal after the pandemic, this goes to the disabled students.
Referring to Higher Education Malaysia, there is an incomplete number of students with disabilities students (Islam, 2015). Nonetheless, Figure 1 shows the number of students with disabilities in Malaysian public universities.  (MOE, 2014(MOE, -2018 In line with students with disabilities, Athira Nortajuddin (2020) reported that people with disabilities are among the world's most marginalised and stigmatised even under normal circumstances," said Jane Buchanan, deputy disability rights director at Human Rights Watch (HRW), see Figure 2. While,  and Menon (2019) defined students with special needs as individuals who differ from societal or community standards for normalcy. These differences may be due to significant physical, sensory, cognitive, or behavioural characteristics. Many of these students may require educational programs customised to their unique needs during the pandemic. Disabilities in learning are problems that affect the brain's ability to receive process, analyse, or store information when a transition happened from face-to-face teaching to online learning. These problems can make it difficult for students to learn as quickly as someone who is not affected by learning disabilities (Rayyan Rafidi, 2020).
Even students may have had physical disabilities or health problems. Students with physical disabilities have problems with the structure or the functioning of their bodies when transitions happened. Devraj and Samsilah Roslan (2006) identify students with special needs as students who need teaching and learning approaches that are different from regular students. Students with special needs students are divided into troubled eyesight, hearing problems and learning disabilities (Devraj & Samsilah, 2006).
In the present study, students with special needs are those who have disabilities severe enough to give a profound effect on normal life, learning and cognitive development (Abdul Rahim, 2006). Meadow and Trybus (1985) reported a higher prevalence of Emotional/Behavior Disorder among deaf students.
Characteristics which identifies an individual as having behavioural disorder are those that have little consideration of social or cultural norms during the pandemic. Therefore, the purpose of the study is to discover the challenges of imperfection students on hearing impairment and to show how it affects the communication and mainstreaming process during Covid-19.

Literature Review
The World Bank estimates that people with disabilities are the fifth of the world's poorest (World Bank, 2010). Disability begets Poverty. It is believed amongst people in developing countries that students with disabilities cannot learn or develop skills, so they are considered to be a burden. This situation has constrained opportunities for the disabled to participate in economic activities that can improve their quality of life. Segregation and marginalisation of disabled people believed to arise from the attitude of the environmental barriers restrict access to disabled people from full educational opportunity.
According to Persons with Disabilities Act of 2008, a disability includes those with long term physical, mental, intellectual or sensory impairments which in interaction with various barriers may hinder their full and active participation in society. Disability is thus, not just a health problem. It is a complex phenomenon, reflecting the interaction between features of a person's body and features of the society in which he or she lives. Overcoming the difficulties faced by people with disabilities requires interventions to remove environmental and social barriers; A person who is unable to decide for him to acquire the whole or part of the normal requirements in their life and social life cannot be entirely due to physical or mental and whether it occurs at birth or thereafter.

www.msocialsciences.com
There are disadvantages or the consequences of hearing impaired related to students' learning processes with hearing impairment. The level of education for students deafened in their infancy is less than those who lose their hearing in a different stage of their life. Their vocabulary and reading skills can really be affected for instance. The preferred learning style of students with hearing loss will generally be visual. It will be challenging for them to learn effectively if the message they receive is only expressed verbally. Technology such as FM systems can be a handy tool for them during the lecture (Chung, Subramaniam & Christ, 2020). The impact of hard-of-hearing can be seen in terms of time. It takes a lot of time for students who require recorded information to receive it. This causes many problems to them as their self-esteem and confidence might go down.

Past Studies
Studies show that the three components: cognitive, affective and behaviourial represents the emotional portion of an attitude, whereas beliefs, ideas and opinions refer to the cognitive component. A person's willingness to interact with the subject at hand including the manner in which the do so best describes the behaviourial component. Attitudes consist of three mechanisms: emotional, cognitive, and behavioural (Olson & Zanna, 1993). The emotional represents the affective part of an attitude, whereas the cognitive refers to thoughts, thinking, and views (Antonak & Livneh, 1988). The behavioural describes a person 's keenness to interrelate with the matter which they do so (Cook, 1992).
In research relating to disability, the importance of understanding issues around the disabled is often under-appreciated. Considerable expertise is needed to address its issue and to help perhaps people understand more towards the disabled. As long as there is a negative attitude towards the disabled, people still cannot accept their presence, and the integration of disabled people in society will be closed (Yusmarhaini Yusof, Cheong, Azlin Hilma Hillaluddin, Fatimah Zailly Ahmad Ramli & Zarina Mat Saad, 2019). Factors that can change negative attitudes towards disabled people are informed about the group and direct contact with them. More information about disabled people known to the community, the less negative stereotypes about the disabled and the more positive their attitude towards disabled people (Mathers, 2003) and similarly, direct contacts with disabled people improve their attitude towards disabled people.
Students with hearing loss can find the classroom a challenging environment and this can lead to social isolation. Not being able to interact with other students may affect the learning process. They are not motivated to take part in tutorials. If they cannot follow the progress of the lecturer, they might not learn effectively. As Doyle (2002) remarks that the importance of hearing is often underestimated mainly because, for the most part, it is an invisible disability. The lack of understanding of hearing loss is further compounded by the tendency to classify the ability to hear into two categories: hearing and deaf. There is a diversity of definitions of hearing impairment. Thus, comparison among studies is difficult. We use WHO classification that classified hearing impairment according to the pure tone average in the better hearing ear. Categories of hearing impairment range from "no impairment" to "profound impairment" according to the threshold level (Mathers, 2003). Based on the findings of Mohd. Sharani Ahmad (2004), a total of 24 of 141 students in four schools in the Klang Valley, Selangor was now wearing hearing aids. The examination results also found that 38.5% of hearing aid batteries are weak and produce a sound that is not clear. 35.9% of the students found mould their ear hearing aids are dirty and clogged. Pupils are very severe; hearing loss can hardly detect the sounds of the spoken speech but with the help of hearing aids. Attention and teaching methods on children's hearing is different from students with special needs and the other due to the difference in their problems and needs. Only 39 hearing aids used by the 24 students who participated in this study. Hearing aids do not work well when there are some problems such as the sounds are not clear; the battery is low, dirty and clogged ear mould and so on. The lack of knowledge by teachers and parents about hearing aids because they cannot repair the device in the event of damage. Not all types of damage to hearing aid to be sent to a specialist (Mohd. Sharani Ahmad, 2004). Based on the discussed literature reviews, it has been found that there are still lack of studies conducted on the challenges of hearing impaired students during Covid-19 pandemic. www.msocialsciences.com

Setting
The data was collected from MySkill Foundation, which is located in Klang Valley, Malaysia, and it is also known as MySkills Transformation Center. This institution provides skills courses such as culinary arts, electric and electronic and also courses on social or public awareness. The consent was obtained to conduct the research from the organisation as well as the participants. Due to ethical concerns, the identity of the participants was kept anonymous.

Sampling
There were ten students participated in this study. Seven females and three males. Among these 10 participants, three with the hearing aid device and the rest were not. They were in mid of obtaining the hearing aids as they are required several procedures. These participants were after SPM (Malaysian Certificate Examination), and their results were not favourable to enter any private colleges or universities to pursue their tertiary courses. They were moderately severe hearing loss, 56-70 hearing loss range (db HL). These participants were from a culinary arts course, and they were relying on reading, visual as well as spoken instructions to pursue the course.

Data collection and Analysis Procedures
The data was collected via impromptu interview questions via WhatsApp as all the students have refrained from the contacts during Covid-19 pandemic. The interviews were conducted into two sessions; the first interview was with five-participant, and the second was with another five-participant. There were no standard interview questions constructed. The questions were based on the objective of the study as Miles and Huberman (1994) noted that for an impromptu interview, a structured or a semistructured interview question may not necessary as the impromptu questions can be asked about the context and repeatedly asked until get the accurate information till meet the objective of the study.

Analysis And Discussion
The responses of the subjects were analysed to identify the challenges faced by hearing impaired students during Covid-19. Through interview following four challenges emerged and summarised from the ten students: The findings show that there were four challenges faced by the hearing impairment students; hearing devices, disruption to comprehend the lesson, not familiar with the online devices and emotionally affected during online classes.
The study aimed at identifying the challenges faced by hearing impairment students during Covid-19. The findings have found that no one can fight destiny determined over events occurring on earth by God. Every human is born like himself in the perfect condition physically, mentally, emotionally and socially. Then, you also have another set of humans who unfortunately are born with lesser means of livelihood; disabled to function aptly like the rest of us. Disabled students are looked upon as a burden, and not to become active contributors to the community and society at large.
Society should understand the special students that they have dreams and ambitions to be active in social, economic and political after they left school (Mohd. Sharani, 2004). Hajah Hasnah (1988 asserts that the early signs that may be available in students should be taken seriously and brought to see a physician to find out any deficiency in them.
The concern of the parents will be able to reduce the burden and reassure the students that belong to those with special needs to survive. Therefore, the community, especially parents, need advice, knowledge and assistance so that individual students can be appropriately guided during Covid-19 pandemic.
Signs that show that students who have hearing problems were not favour to online classes online classes, seems always to daydream, talking is not clear, was surprised when approached from behind, do not understand the instructions given and poor performance especially concerning language. Cognitive developments are a bit slow due to delays in language development. For social development, it depends on their experience, how the services were received, and through their development capabilities in online classes. www.msocialsciences.com

Implication of the Study
This study carries a heavy weightage for parents when an abnormal symptom can be seen from a student during any types of pandemics. The impact could be seen when students' loss hearing while the consequences also could affect a students' future. Thus, teachers and parents play an important role in ensuring the students' auditory performance, educational achievements, spoken communication skills and quality of life during the pandemic. They consider the sensitivity of the privacy of the students in the case and the honour and dignity of the parents and family members. Being a case study, the findings may not be general and thus may not apply to the other cases with similar pandemics. Skillsbased colleges should provide necessary facilities for disabling, students, during the pandemic. Therefore, they are not hindered. This also should be monitored by the Higher learning intuitions that those skills-based colleges have specific facilities for disabled students. The main weakness of this study was the paucity of number of participants. It is good to have more participants to elicit more information on the challenges during the pandemic. This study was also limited by the absence of instructors to interview them to see what the challenges are they face to teach these hearing impairment students during the pandemic.

Conclusion
The present study can be concluded that by giving you some strategies that teachers and parents should follow to facilitate the learning of the deaf or hearing impaired during the pandemic. There are many ways to help teachers aid the students to learn to face the challenges, but some particular strategies exist to teach students to face challenges with hearing impairment during any pandemics. A teacher should always motivate this group physically and mentally and train them to face a challenge. Apart from the challenges, teachers make sure these students use the FM (frequency modulation) hearing systems if the online classes are equipped with them. Hearing aid microphone for the instructor. With such a microphone, the teacher can keep up with his way of speaking and teaching, but they should make sure that it is adjusted so that it lessens the background noise. Make sure the questions are wellcomprehended by students before answering them. Encourage the recording of your lectures. You can even copy your notes and distribute them to your students. Finally develop the reading skills of your students with hearing loss by encouraging them to read early before each class. Several questions still remain to be answered, further study can be looked at the communication skills. The study can be done by assigning an online role-play activity in a classroom to improve their communication skills, especially on the clarity, conciseness, completeness and correctness (Truman, 2011).
All institutions of higher learning must assign a special task force to facilitate students with impairments. The task force could recognise the prospective requirements of students and plan precise guidelines for faculty personnel in carrying out online learning, recorded lectures, mid-term tests, tasks and undertakings. There should be some leeway for students who cannot partake in an online study on account of some matters. Furthermore, universities must make sure of mental health assistance by affording health and safety policies, including managing anxiety that could result from maintaining social distancing. University counselling centers should provide online assistance to help students if the need arises. Other centers such as examination and admission centers can be improved with online capabilities for students with impairments in having access to results and registering for courses.